What is more expensive to glue wallpaper or decorative plaster. What is better to choose for wall decoration - liquid wallpaper or decorative plaster

It is necessary to decide on the choice of how to cover the walls in the rooms long before the start of repair work in order to calculate the estimate. And the main materials between which you have to choose are wallpaper or decorative plaster. It would seem that since plaster is a fairly versatile material, it can be the basis for wallpaper or an independent wall covering, then all the advantages behind it, but no, everything is not so simple. To determine which is better, plaster or wallpaper, you can only compare them with each other in all respects.

So let's start with durability. This is an important factor in interior decoration, because with the constant threat of a crisis, the next repair may simply be unaffordable, which means that the wall covering should last as long as possible. As for the plaster, it all depends on its type. So, for example, silicone plaster can last up to 60 years if applied with high quality, silicate and polymer plaster - up to 50 years, mineral - rarely longer than 30. Of course, wallpaper cannot last such a long time, with the exception of liquid wallpaper. Even reliable fiberglass wallpaper lasts 10-20 years with careful handling, while metal wallpapers are easily scratched, quickly losing their beauty.

We go further - the price. Here, too, everything is debatable, since good plaster costs about 350 rubles per square meter. But in general, the price range starts from 180 and ends with 1000 rubles per square meter, and this includes the prices for Venetian plaster. Wallpaper, of course, is much cheaper: single-layer ones cost about 50 rubles per roll, two-layer ones - from 80 to 100 rubles per roll, you can find inexpensive silk-screen printing within 200 rubles. However, there are really expensive, extremely beautiful and durable wallpapers, and among them are textile ones at 600 rubles per linear meter, as well as metal ones at $ 25 per meter with a roll width of 0.686 meters. The cheapest liquid wallpaper can be found for 150 rubles (quality is not guaranteed at all), and on average they cost about 450 rubles, although there are brands whose price goes off scale for one and a half thousand.

Wall plastering under wallpaper or without them, which is preferable

As mentioned above, plaster often becomes the basis for wallpaper, and does this mean that it is she who should be awarded the award in the nomination "best material of the century"? Perhaps not, since wallpaper still competes with plaster. Liquid wallpaper is a wonderful material, almost in no way inferior to plaster, with the exception of strength. However, at the same time, liquid wallpaper also has a clear advantage - if some area of ​​\u200b\u200bthe coating is damaged, it is enough just to scrape off the mass frozen on the wall, soak the appropriate amount of new material and cover up the damaged area. With decorative plaster, such a trick will not work.

What happens, liquid wallpaper can last almost forever? Almost, if you do not take into account the changing tastes of homeowners. Yes, and the same wall covering can simply get bored. However, there is another advantage of liquid wallpaper - you can remove the entire coating and apply a new one, but of a different color. As for decorative plaster, its advantage is a huge margin of safety. It is known that when Rome was captured, the barbarians chipped off pieces of plaster and found use for them as countertops, or even used them completely outside the box - as mirrors. Yes, stucco can be extremely durable, and when properly processed, it can achieve an almost mirror-like finish.

Wallpaper or decorative plaster - simpler means better?

For beginners in the repair epic, the most acceptable option always seems to be the one that will take less effort, provided that a satisfactory result is obtained (the main thing is not mediocre). Therefore, those who have experience in wallpapering and at the same time are afraid to take up a spatula will definitely prefer wallpaper. Well, those who do not grab the stars from the sky at all in the repair field will probably decide to try their hand at applying plaster. So which is better, plaster or wallpaper? What's easier?

So, before sticking the wallpaper, you need to prepare the surface of the walls, giving them maximum smoothness. Then the walls must be primed with drying oil or wallpaper paste. After waiting for complete drying, we measure the desired length of the wallpaper, cut it off, lay it on the floor with the wrong side up and coat it with glue. While it dries up (so that it does not dry out at all, it is better to fold a piece of wallpaper in half), we spread a section of the wall. We apply wallpaper to the wall and gently rub it so as not to tear off the decorative layer and at the same time so as not to leave bubbles. Let's move on to the next piece.

It is not necessary to prepare the wall for applying decorative plaster, on the contrary, it is better to distort its surface more strongly in order to obtain an ideal adhesion of the mixture to the wall. Smearing with force on pre-primed wall(the only stage of preparation for plastering) the first layer of plaster, we get a dense coating. When it dries, apply a new layer, after removing all unreliable protrusions. And so on up to 3-5 layers. At the end, we carefully rub the plaster with the finest sandpaper and voila - the wall covering is ready.

Even wonderful liquid wallpaper is not applied without prior preparation - wall plastering for wallpaper is simply necessary. Thus, we come to the conclusion that with little experience in repair work, plaster is still better. Moreover, she, with proper processing, is also beautiful in her own way.

An important factor, since not each of us has the opportunity to change wall coverings often. The service life of plaster depends on its variety, for example, silicone can last about 60 years, silicate and polymer - up to half a century, mineral - up to 30. Of course, wallpapers cannot boast of such durability: even the most reliable of them (fiberglass) will please their owners for no more than 10-20 years.

The appearance of the walls decorated with plaster will be attractive, of high quality and durable, if you responsibly approach not only the choice of material and tools, but also qualified specialists.

Wallpaper disadvantages:

• Paper wallpapers are not waterproof, easily torn right during application to the surface (do not overdo it with glue);

• Textile wallpapers attract dust, so they need to be removed and washed regularly;

• Washable wallpaper is hard to stick to the walls, requires an exceptionally dry surface;

• If the pasting technology is violated, mold may appear under the wallpaper;

• Wallpaper can not decorate rooms with high humidity and external walls.

But wallpaper is glued to any surface (prefabricated panels, aerated concrete, brick, plaster), and everyone can work with them, even without special skills.

Price question: which is cheaper?

Cosmetic repairs will cost you a ridiculous amount if you limit yourself to wallpapering walls from inexpensive paper material without first preparing the walls. Vinyl and non-woven wallpaper will cost more - they are able to hide some surface flaws. Newfangled seamless coatings, the cost of which reaches several thousand rubles per meter, will hit the wallet even more.

As for plaster, there are many varieties of it: Venetian, graffito, Danish, bark beetle. Their cost in terms of square meters can be quite high, and only a professional can apply any of the listed materials to the walls.

It should be noted that it is necessary to choose between plaster and wallpaper, focusing on their cost, taking into account the perspective, because plaster is much more reliable than any other coatings.

The benefits of plastering

• Variable, versatile and unique plaster has a high level of plasticity.

• With its help, you can skillfully recreate a wide variety of surfaces: marble, onyx, granite, fabric, leather, wood.

• Plaster allows you to endlessly experiment with shades and patterns.

• This material is applied seamlessly, and the surface made with it is easy to clean, indifferent to the sun's rays and "breathes".

• All types of plaster are resistant to mechanical stress.

• This coating does not require serious surface preparation.

• The plaster does not absorb foreign odors and has a sound-absorbing effect.

Benefits of wallpaper stickers

• Minimal expenditure of time and money.

• Possibility to make repairs with your own hands.

• The ability to hide defects made by builders.

• The widest range of products, a variety of styles, patterns and ornaments.

• The ability to simulate a wide range of finishing materials.

Plaster - the best material of the century?

Plaster often becomes the "foundation" for wallpaper, but does this mean that this material can be called the only, inimitable and irreplaceable? Perhaps not, because for several years plaster has been competing with liquid wallpaper, which has one significant advantage over its more “adult” counterpart. It lies in the fact that any damaged area of ​​​​the coating can be simply removed (scraped off the hardened mass) and again covered with an appropriate amount of new soaked material.

Pros of liquid wallpaper

• This material does not require perfect alignment of surfaces before application.

• It can be applied to both horizontal and vertical surfaces.

• The jointless coating easily fills any gaps.

• Liquid wallpaper has good heat and sound insulating properties.

• They absorb excess moisture, do not attract dust, and contain fungicides that prevent dampness and mold.

• Working with liquid wallpaper is a pleasure. They do not have a pungent odor, do not generate dust and do not require special skills.

Against the background of numerous advantages, the disadvantages of liquid wallpaper do not look so impressive: the high price and the need to dry the walls within a day after applying the material.

Summing up

Decorative plaster is a material that is less prone to wear and mechanical damage, pleasing with a variety of colors and methods of application. With a relatively small difference in cost, plaster is superior to ordinary wallpaper in all respects: it is more reliable, stronger, easier to apply and operate, more interesting in terms of design.

Liquid wallpaper in its qualities is much closer to decorative plaster. Representing a synthesis of cotton and cellulose fibers, high-quality dyes and adhesives, they are supplied to the shelves in powder or liquid form, diluted with water-based paint and applied to the walls with a roller or spray gun. It is economical, environmentally friendly, fast, efficient and beautiful.

The last word is yours, because both wallpaper and plaster have a lot of varieties, among which you will certainly find the right “clothes” for your walls.

How to choose a bathroom sink?

Benefits of wallpapering

Before deciding, it is necessary to consider the pros and cons of the two options. So which is better? Let's start with wallpaper.

They are very popular and are now known to everyone. Due to their practicality and low cost, they are glued both in offices and in private homes. However, not everyone knows about the main characteristics. The benefits include:

• wallpapers are made from environmentally friendly substances that do not cause allergies, do not cause any harm to humans or animals;
• wallpaper is a good sound insulator, which gives an undoubted advantage over other coatings. Also, this material does a good job of retaining heat in the room;
• For gluing practically no surface preparation is needed. The material is able to hide minor wall imperfections, such as bumps or cracks. The only thing you need to pay attention to is the choice of high-quality glue;
• Wallpapers are soft and outperform their competitors in beauty. This type of coating guarantees a large selection of design solutions;
• even a beginner can paste wallpaper. The process is quite easy and does not require much effort and investment. This coating is quite cheap, so no special financial costs are required. The main thing is to carefully consider cutting the rolls and follow the instructions provided;
• the material has good throughput, which will provide protection against mold on the walls.

Main selection criteria

The choice of coverage is influenced by a huge number of factors. First of all, you need to take into account personal tastes and the quality of the walls. Consider the main criteria when choosing a finish for the walls:

• The first and, perhaps, the most important criterion is the budget allocated for repairs. If you do not plan to invest a lot of money in repairs, then it would be better to opt for wallpaper. They are cheaper compared to decorative plaster. Also, for the second option, you will need to additionally prepare the wall and, most likely, seek help from specialists, which will greatly affect the final amount of the repair;
• It is worth considering the period for which the repair is planned. If you like to frequently update the design of the room, then wallpaper is better. Conversely, if repairs are planned for many years, plaster will be the best option. With proper handling, it can last more than ten years;
• it is also worth deciding whether you can handle the repair alone or it is better to use the help of a construction team. Do not forget that wallpapering is much easier than applying decorative plaster.

Advice! Keep in mind that if exterior wall decoration is planned, decorative plaster has a clear advantage.

As a result, it is important to note that the choice of coating does not greatly affect the beauty of the room. All factors are purely practical. Ultimately, the choice depends on your personal preferences, tastes or expectations for renovation. The choice can also be influenced by the style in which you want to make repairs. For a classic style, wallpaper with patterns is the best option, and for a modern one, both finishes are suitable. Alternatively, you can apply a combined finish with different colors. It is also worth taking into account the furniture that will be installed in the room.

Which plaster is better

There are a lot of decorative solutions for walls, and each of them has its own advantages. It will not be possible to unequivocally answer which of them is better suited for the wall. Therefore, let's look at each option and analyze its characteristics. So, decorative plaster happens:

• Venetian. When finishing the wall, it imitates a stone coating or fabric. It is often used specifically for interior cladding, but there are varieties that are used for outdoor work. The solution is distinguished by its quality and durability, it is also able to provide a high service life, which can reach twenty years. The mixture has a high rate of vapor permeability, so it is often used for walls in the kitchen or bathroom;
• bark beetle This plaster has the effect of rain and is very popular when processing walls. The bark beetle is chosen for outdoor work and occasionally for interior walls. The mixture is of high quality and good protection against frost, moisture and sunlight;
• mineral. A special stone crumb is added to the composition of this mixture, which allows you to achieve a decorative effect. It can be used for both interior and exterior wall cladding.

As you can see, the choice of plaster depends on your preferences and the type of work. If interior wall decoration is planned, it is better to use a Venetian mixture, and for exterior work, bark beetle or mineral solutions.

Liquid wallpaper

Plastic material for finishing the premises, liquid wallpaper has another name - liquid plaster for walls. It is believed that these wallpapers combine the advantages of roll wallpaper and decorative plaster.

Various colors and shades of liquid wallpaper

Types of liquid wallpaper and their composition

This material is a dry mixture of silk or cellulose fibers, glue, plasticizers, pigments and additional components (mother of pearl, glitter, etc.). Types of liquid wallpaper depend on the main component of the mixture:

1. Silk liquid wallpaper;

The basis of such wallpaper is silk fiber, which gives the finished material durability and high resistance to ultraviolet radiation. The main component not only makes silk liquid wallpaper the highest quality and most attractive, but also affects the price - they are the most expensive.

1. Liquid wallpaper made of cellulose;

Cellulose significantly reduces the cost of wallpaper, while reducing durability. Externally, liquid cellulose wallpaper looks much simpler than silk.

1. Combined view.

The basis of the mixture for liquid cellulose-silk wallpaper includes both cellulose and silk fibers, so this material allows you to get a high-quality, durable and aesthetic wall covering. The cost of such wallpaper is in the middle price segment.

View of interior walls decorated with liquid wallpaper

Application method

Applying liquid wallpaper to the wall is not difficult, but it is important to observe all the nuances of the technology. Wall covering with liquid wallpaper consists of the following steps:

1. Removing the old coating from the walls;
2. Applying a primer to the walls;
3. Preparation of a mixture for liquid wallpaper according to the instructions;
4. Applying the finished mixture to the walls with a spatula or a construction gun;
5. An optional step - if the liquid wallpaper was intended for painting, after complete drying, paint is applied to them.

Applying a mixture of liquid wallpaper to the wall surface with a spatula

Depending on the specific mixture and the temperature in the room, such wallpapers will dry from 12 to 72 hours.

Important! When mixing liquid wallpaper, the entire package is used at once, otherwise the percentage composition of the components from an incomplete package will significantly change the characteristics of the material.

Price

To understand the real price that it will cost to cover the walls with liquid wallpaper, it is worth starting from the cost of covering 1 m² with this material.

The price range for a standard package of liquid wallpaper in 1 kg ranges from 150 to 800 rubles. Some manufacturers claim that one package of the mixture is enough to cover 5m², however, in practice, a mixture from one package is enough for about 4m² of the surface. It turns out that the price for covering 1 m² of walls with liquid wallpaper will cost from 37 to 200 rubles, depending on the type of material chosen.

Decorative plaster

This material, which allows you to create a unique pattern and relief on the walls, as well as all kinds of imitation effects, has long been in demand for surface finishing.

Types of decorative plasters and their composition

The composition of decorative plaster includes the main components, binders, water base, as well as all kinds of thickeners, fillers and additives.

1. Textured decorative plaster;

A relatively inexpensive material that allows you to get a three-dimensional surface effect, is the most popular of all types of decorative plasters. The main fillers are wood fibers, small pebbles and mica.

View of the surface of the wall, decorated with textured plaster

1. Structural plaster;

The basis of this mixture is a fine-grained mineral filler (in particular, quartz), which makes the finished surface fairly uniform. Most often, such decorative plaster is used to create shallow visual imitations, for example, tree bark.

Visual effects on the surface of structural plaster

1. Venetian plaster;

This material, which is based on mineral chips, is used to create a smooth and shiny coating that resembles marble.

Imitation of a marble surface on a wall using Venetian plaster

1. Flock plaster.

The youngest type of decorative plaster consists of an adhesive base, small fragments of different colors - flocks, and a varnish coating. It is in this order that the components are applied to the wall.

Variegated particles - flocks, on the surface of flocked plaster

According to the composition, decorative plaster is also divided into acrylic, silicone, mineral and silicate. All these four types of finishing materials are successfully used both for finishing walls in rooms and for facade walls.

Silicate plaster is most often used as a decorative plaster for outdoor applications. This is due to the composition of this type of material. It is based on potash glass, and it is believed that during operation, silicate plaster can release substances hazardous to human health. However, many repair specialists choose this type of plaster for finishing aerated concrete surfaces.

Depending on the type of plaster chosen, the process of applying it to the wall may include different steps, but the main ones are:

1. Removal from the walls of the previous coating;
2. Wall primer (the type of primer is selected based on the composition of the mixture);
3. Preparation of the mixture according to the instructions (if the selected type of plaster requires it);
4. Applying the composition in an even layer on the wall section;
5. Creation of a relief with the help of special tools after the mixture "grabs" a little;
6. After about 20 minutes, when the gloss on the surface disappears, a gentle smoothing of the relief;
7. Alignment of small irregularities with sandpaper after complete drying of the composition;
8. Finishing the finished surface, if necessary - painting, gilding, etc.

Important! When applying Venetian plaster, the sequence is different and includes several stages that require experience and skill.

You can watch the following video, in which the master clearly shows how to get an interesting effect on the wall if you apply ordinary paint to decorative plaster:

A standard 25kg bag of decorative plaster costs from 550 to 3600 rubles, this variation is due to the different composition and brand of the manufacturer. Consumption per 1 m² ranges from 1.5 to 4 kg, depending on the type of plaster chosen. Thus, the cost of covering 1 m² of surface with decorative plaster will cost from 140 to 2400 rubles. Of course, the upper limit can be higher, sometimes there are compositions with extremely expensive elite fillers.

Advantages and disadvantages of coatings

To compare liquid wallpaper and decorative plaster, consider the main advantages and disadvantages of each of these types of coatings.

1. Advantages:
   • Ease of preparation of the mixture and application to the walls;
   • No seams;
   • Hide the unevenness of the walls;
   • Allow the walls to "breathe";
   • Environmental friendliness;
   • Low cost;
   • The ability to restore a section of the wall in case of damage during operation;
   • Easy to remove from the walls during subsequent repairs;
   • Nice appearance.

1. Flaws:
   • A small variety of colors and textures;
   • Moisture resistance.

Ease of restoring a damaged section of the wall with liquid wallpaper

1. Advantages:
   • High coating strength;
   • Environmental friendliness;
   • No seams;
   • Hides uneven walls;
   • Ease of care - can be washed with water and cleaned with a vacuum cleaner;
   • Allows the walls to "breathe";
   • Huge opportunities for design solutions.

1. Flaws:
   • More expensive;
   • It is difficult to restore the damaged area;
   • The process of removing from the walls is quite laborious;
   • Some types of plasters require special skills in application.

A variety of imitations and decorative wall finishes using decorative plaster

Conclusion

When choosing between decorative plaster and liquid wallpaper, it is important to answer a few questions for yourself:

1. What is the budget for finishing?

Decorative plaster, even in the middle price segment, will cost much more than elite liquid wallpaper. In addition, plastering can require high surface preparation costs.

1. Are there animals in the house that can damage the walls?

Liquid wallpaper makes it easy to restore the damaged area. It is enough to dilute a small piece of wallpaper that has survived after repair with water and apply it to the section of the wall that needs restoration.

1. When is the next renovation scheduled and how long do you plan to live in the house?

If you have plans for the future to change your place of residence or the owner is used to making repairs often, it is easier to choose liquid wallpaper.

1. Which room is being renovated?

1. Are special visual effects desirable?

In this regard, decorative plaster leaves liquid wallpaper far behind, allowing you to create countless unique and spectacular surfaces, including imitation leather, tree bark, marble, etc.

Both considered materials are an excellent solution for finishing - they help to hide the bumps and imperfections of the walls, do not require perfect alignment (the exception is Venetian plaster), are easy to apply and allow you to get a visually attractive surface without seams. Each of them can be optimal depending on the specific situation, so which one is best for your home is up to you.

Excellent article 0

General advantages and disadvantages

If you turn to encyclopedic reference books, you can find such a characteristic of decorative plaster - this is the finishing layer of a hardened mortar of alabaster, lime or gypsum, applied to the walls and ceiling to give the surface an aesthetic appearance.

Liquid wallpaper, in principle, is the same decorative plaster, i. a hardened layer of the mixture applied to the walls for their finishing. The following facts speak of the confusion of concepts: in TU, liquid wallpaper is designated by the term "silk plaster", and Wikipedia refers to silk plaster as one of the types of decorative wallpaper. There is another confusing term - "Danish decorative plaster", which is actually liquid wallpaper.

In order not to get confused, you need to understand what is the difference between these finishing materials. Their main and only difference is that there is quartz sand in the composition of decorative plaster, but it is not in liquid wallpaper - it is replaced by cellulose.

One more thing is surprising - these materials have almost the same advantages. If we talk about the merits, then they are:

• applied to walls made of any material: plasterboard, brick, stone, concrete, wood;
• hide the imperfections of the surface of the wall or ceiling: cracks, cracks, shells, chips;
• allow you to create various patterns and full-fledged drawings, while in color;
• have good soundproofing properties;
• regulate the microclimate in the room due to the ability to "breathe";
• good heaters;
• have a long service life;
• belong to an environmentally friendly finishing material - the components of the mixture are not hypoallergenic;
• do not have seams and joints - a solid surface is more aesthetic in appearance and durable;
• do not have waste in the form of paper scraps, adhesive mass residues, etc.

At the same time, there is still a difference between decorative plaster and liquid wallpaper.

Such plaster has additional advantages:

• high surface strength - it is difficult to damage mechanically;
• easy care - the wall is cleaned with a wet cloth or vacuum cleaner;
• not afraid of water, so you can plaster rooms with high humidity (bathroom, kitchen);
• it is also used for outdoor work - withstands temperature differences from -55 to +60 degrees Celsius;
• has great potential for the implementation of various design ideas;
• keeps saturated bright color all term of operation.

The disadvantages include:

• high cost of finishing;
• difficulty in restoring damaged areas (in most cases, restoration is impossible);
• can not be applied to walls in houses that shrink - it cracks;
• the laborious process of removing from the walls during replacement;
• professionals are required to perform the work - a complex and time-consuming plastering technology.

Among the advantages inherent only in liquid wallpaper, stand out:

• elasticity - withstand any shrinkage and do not crack;
• do not require experience or training - work is within the power of any beginner;
• budget cost of finishing;
• ease of removal when switching to another type of finish;
• can be restored if damaged during operation;
• pleasant appearance and texture - soft to the touch, reminiscent of silk.

For information: for repairs, you can use frozen mixtures remaining after the completion of the finishing work.

• afraid of moisture - can only be used in living rooms and hallways;
• cannot be used for facade decoration;
• limited in color and texture;
• under the influence of ultraviolet rays quickly fade.

Comparison of technical and operational characteristics

The above advantages and disadvantages do not answer the question: what is better - liquid wallpaper or decorative plaster? To continue the comparison, we will analyze the technical, technological and operational characteristics of these types of finishes.

It does not have a specific composition. She has different binders, fillers and thickeners. The only component included in all possible plaster solutions is quartz sand, used in the form of additives.

The most popular types of decorative plaster are:

• Mineral. The binder is cement. Moisture resistant. Has a small price;
• Polymer. Acrylic based. Very plastic and durable, resistant to aggressive environments;
• Silicone. The main component is silicone resin. The pluses include the ability not to retain dust on its surface;
• Silicate plaster is made on the basis of liquid glass. Resistant to mold and fungus, delays open flame in the process of fire.

The type of filler determines the aesthetic characteristics of the plaster.

Particles of mica, wood fibers and small stones give textured (textural) decorative plaster, which in turn can have varieties:

• "Lamb" - the surface is even, granular. From the side it resembles soft wool;
• "Fur coat" - the plastered wall is similar to the previous finish, but not soft, but fleecy;
• "Bark beetle" - a very popular view, in which the walls resemble old wood, undermined by a bark beetle - passages are visible.

Already from the name it is clear that textured plaster has a pronounced texture, which allows you to hide all the imperfections of the wall under the plaster layer. At the same time, the application technology is the simplest: you can do the work yourself.

1 of 4

Structural plaster is based on the finest quartz sand and mica. To obtain an unusual surface texture, wood fibers or silk in the form of threads are sometimes added. After applying such a solution, the wall has a homogeneous structure, on which imitation of tree bark, sandstone, etc. can be applied with special rollers.

1 of 5

Venetian plaster perfectly imitates real marble. This is facilitated by special mineral fillers: marble, granite and quartz chips. At the same time, with a decrease in the size of the filler fractions, the pattern becomes softer and deeper.

1 of 5

The plaster is sold ready to use. It has a translucent appearance. It is tinted in the color of marble with which it is planned to finish the room. Its peculiarity is that with each plaster layer, the finish becomes more luxurious, playing with different shades. To enhance the effect of natural stone, the surface of the wall is waxed and polished.

A novelty in the construction market is flock decorative plaster. It is based on several layers applied in a certain sequence to the wall: glue, then multi-colored flocks (they are also called chips) of acrylic paint, and varnish on top (this type of plaster does not fit into the classical definitions - it does not contain quartz sand).

1 of 4

Depending on the filler, they are:

• cotton;
• silk;
• cellulose;
• combined (silk-cellulose).

Cotton wallpaper. Very similar to decorative plaster - even experts do not always immediately determine the type of finishing material. They consist of cotton and cellulose fibers, decorative fillers and mineral additives.

They have a non-standard texture, which allows, as in the case of plaster, to create various panels and stucco moldings. If necessary, strengthen the color palette - additionally paint. The disadvantage of such wallpapers is a rather high price.

Cotton liquid wallpaper.

Silk wallpaper. The most expensive type (without the cost of work). As part of silk and cotton fibers, mineral fillers, dyes and glue.

For your information: the components of cotton and silk wallpapers are similar. The difference is in the amount of fiber of each type in each type of liquid plaster.

The smooth texture is diversified: by embossing with a special roller, curly spatula, cutting the relief with a stick or a variety of sparkles (glitter). Due to this property of the texture, the wallpaper is universal - it can be used in any room with any interior. If necessary, you can additionally paint. Slightly fade under direct UV rays, and therefore have a long service life without additional repainting

1 of 3

Cellulose wallpaper. Based on wood fibers, and therefore it is the cheapest type of liquid wallpaper. Accordingly, they also have lower performance indicators: in appearance they are unpresentable, in terms of service life they are short-lived.

Silk-cellulose wallpaper. A more profitable option for wall decoration - the addition of silk removes all the shortcomings of cellulose wallpaper, except for the main one - the service life increases, but only slightly.

Comparison of the various characteristics of these finishes still does not make it clear where to stop, and at the same time even more confusing. Therefore, we compare the cost factor.

What is cheaper

To understand what is cheaper, you need to start not from the price of a unit of material, but from the cost of 1 m2 of a wall covered with each type of finish - then it turns out to take into account the material consumption per unit area and the cost of finishing work.

Liquid wallpaper. The cost of 1 kg starts from 150 rubles. But it is a cellulose-based material. Combined and cotton ones cost 250-550 rubles. For calculations, we take the average value - 400 rubles / kg. The consumption of the mixture per unit area in practice is higher than indicated by the manufacturers and is 4 m2 versus 5 m2. Therefore, for the purchase of materials per square meter of the wall, you need to spend 100 rubles.

The cost of work starts from 250 rubles / m2. In reality, you can order a master for 300 rubles. Total 1 m2 of wall costs 400 rubles.

For reference: 1 m2 of silk wallpaper will cost 1150-1300 rubles. for 1 m2. But, we emphasize, this is the most expensive type of liquid wallpaper.

Decorative plaster. For the price (a bag of 25 kg) it has a huge spread - from 500 rubles. up to 4000 rub. The average price range is 1000-2000 rubles. for packing. Consumption, depending on the type of plaster, ranges from 1.5 kg/m2 to 4 kg/m2. Let's stop at an average value of 2.5 kg / m2. Then the cost of decorative plaster per 1 m2 of the wall will be 150 rubles / m2 (1500 rubles / 25 kg / 2.5 kg / m2).

You can order a master for 300-1200 rubles / m2. At the same time, the price of 300-350 rubles / m2 applies exclusively to phlox plaster. For other types, it starts at a price of 450 rubles / m2. As a result, the application of decorative plaster will cost at least 600 rubles / m2, on average 850-950 rubles / m2. The most expensive plaster costs about 5.0-6.0 thousand rubles. for 1 m2.

Conclusion: if we start from the cost factor, the task: decorative plaster or liquid wallpaper - what to choose is easy to solve. Liquid wallpaper is much cheaper, especially since cotton and silk types are difficult to distinguish from textured and structural plaster.

What is easier to apply

The technology for applying each type of decorative plaster has its own characteristics, but in general, the process can be described in the following steps:

• the wall surface is cleaned of old finishing material and repaired, then primed and plastered, after which it is primed again;
• the working mixture is prepared in accordance with the instructions printed on the package;
• the composition is applied in a uniform layer on the wall;
• after setting the mixture with the help of embossed rollers, an embossing of the surface is formed;
• after the disappearance of the gloss (after 20 minutes), the surface is smoothed in order to remove the sharp edges of the relief;
• after the plaster has completely dried, it is polished with fine-grained sandpaper.

The process of applying liquid wallpaper is simpler:

• the old wall decoration (paint, wallpaper) is removed, after which cracks and chips are repaired;
• the surface is primed under the mixture chosen for application;
• the composition is prepared in accordance with the instructions printed on the package;

Important: the whole pack is poured out, otherwise the proportions of the components will be violated.

• with a spatula, the mixture is applied to the wall;
• after complete drying, the surface of the wall is painted (the operation is not required for painted wallpapers).

From the comparison of technologies, it can be seen that the execution of plastering work is more laborious, while liquid wallpaper can be applied independently.

Until recently, the choice of material for wall decoration was small, most people preferred wallpaper: smooth paper, vinyl, non-woven, with a convex texture or for painting. Over time, wall decoration with a decorative mixture, which is a wonderful decoration of the interior, came into fashion.

Today, canvases have appeared that imitate textured plaster, as well as such an expensive type of decorative finish as venetian. In order to decide how to finish, you should know the advantages and disadvantages of both methods. To decide what is better wallpaper or decorative plaster, our gallery will help you: examples of different finishes in the interior.

Practicality and durability

Repair is a rather expensive business, so it is better to choose a material for wall decoration that will not only look great, but also last a long time. Rare wallpapers can please the eye for longer than 5 years. Even non-woven and their types will not last longer than 10 years on the walls, despite the fact that they can be repeatedly painted. The only exception is glass cloth material, but their service life is no more than 15-20 years.

Decorative mixture will last much longer. A well-applied silicone finish can last up to 60 years, a polymer or silicate finish can last up to 50 years, and a mineral finish can last up to 30 years. Decorative plaster can be washed and cleaned, and cracked finishes can be easily repaired and repaired.

It is almost impossible to distinguish wallpaper under plaster in the interior

Wallpaper or decorative plaster: labor intensity, speed and cost of work

If the house has even smooth walls, then pasting them with canvases is the fastest option. However, in practice, it turns out that in order to glue the walls with high quality, they have to be prepared, remove the old putty from the concrete walls, apply a primer, and level the surfaces.

Unlike rolled material, textured plaster can be applied even on defective surfaces, masking them due to its texture.

Decorative putty looks expensive and elegant on the walls

When asked what is cheaper roll material or decorative plaster, the answer is obvious - it all depends on the quality of the selected coating. For example, seamless wallpaper can cost several thousand rubles per roll, and if you add the cost of a primer, wall putty, then the price of finishing will be quite high. In this case, textured decorative plaster will be cheaper.

Non-woven fabrics are very similar to plaster

Wallpaper imitating plaster

Some types of plaster, such as Venetian, not only have a high cost, but also require professional skills and craftsmanship to apply. In this regard, Venetian plaster wallpapers imitating marble finishes are gaining popularity. They create a feeling of luxury in the interior and have already earned a lot of rave reviews.

Thanks to a thick layer of vinyl applied on a durable paper backing, stucco-look wallpaper not only repeats the colors of the Venetian finish, but, unlike ordinary ones, repels dust and creates a visual expansion of the space thanks to its matte finish with iridescent effects. Plaster effect wallpapers are easy to clean with soapy water, they are durable and resistant to fading.

Plastered wallpaper in the interior looks elegant and stylish. However, their main advantage lies also in how much this material costs. It is an order of magnitude cheaper than a decorative mixture of this type.

Wallpaper for decorative plaster, the photo shows an imitation of the Venetian finish

Comparison with liquid wallpaper

Another great option is to choose liquid wallpaper. The main thing that distinguishes this type of finish from the rest is the ability to quickly restore damaged areas. They are sold in the form of a dry or ready-made mixture, which is diluted with warm water. Natural cotton fibers, high-quality dyes, adhesive binder - these are the main components of this material.

A modern finish that can be applied even to uneven walls

Silk plaster liquid wallpaper in combination with spectacular lighting creates a unique, cozy atmosphere in the room. This material looks expensive and elegant in any interior. So what to choose - liquid wallpaper or decorative plaster? We can say that both types of finishes are of excellent quality. Difficulties can arise only when applying the material to the walls, in the first, in the second case, therefore, choosing between them, the difference will only be in price.

Silk liquid material in the interior looks like an expensive decorative putty

It is possible to qualitatively cover the walls with plaster with your own hands if you have certain skills, especially when it comes to Venetian, wet silk, Marseille wax.

Gluing wallpapers that imitate textured plaster is, of course, easier and you can do without the help of professionals, but even the highest quality wallpapers cannot be compared with an exquisite expensive decorative coating. If the decisive factor for you is the price - the cost of material and work, then of course it is better to give preference to wallpaper.

If you are going to finish the walls with inexpensive decorative plaster for painting, perhaps this option will be better than wallpaper, because the color of the finish can be changed repeatedly, and unlike wallpaper, plaster can stay on the walls for many years.

When we select wall finishes, often the choice is between some materials. Along with the common option - wallpaper, a lot of other types of finishes have appeared that can compete with them, including. This is decorative plaster. Therefore, more and more often the question arises, what is better to use - wallpaper or plaster. Which coating is more reliable, more beautiful, more suitable in a particular room, etc.? Naturally, there cannot be one answer to all these questions, but we can help you make the only right decision for yourself.

It may seem to many that the advantage in this dispute is with plaster, since it can act as an independent finishing material, or be the basis for wallpaper. But not everything is so simple: in order to understand all the pros and cons, you need to carefully analyze these two materials in all respects.

Durability

Decorative piece

When making repairs, we all think about finances and want the wall covering to last as long as possible, because with constant threats of a crisis, the next repair may not be soon. In terms of durability plaster shows amazing results: so, silicone can last even 60 years, silicate - a little less, about 50 years, and mineral - about 30. Wallpapers cannot boast of such characteristics: everything is clear with paper, metal scratches during operation, and even the most reliable fiberglass on average, they serve 15 years. So, in this parameter, the leader is obvious.

True, they can become an exception: although they are not as durable as decorative plaster, they have a greater margin of maintainability. So, if some kind of scratch has formed, you can simply scrape off a piece of the coating, dilute part of the new one, and eliminate the defect. Unfortunately, this will not work with plaster.

Although it should also be noted that the issue of durability for some may not be a priority, since many people quickly get bored with the same type of walls, and if you change the coating every 5-10 years, then, probably, wallpaper and plaster show themselves the same way. Here again, you need to get out of your own needs and capabilities.

Price

Initially it seems that plaster is much more expensive than wallpaper: this is true if we compare the average prices in the market. But it is worth remembering that there are also exclusive types of wallpaper that will stand, if not the same as plaster, then a little more expensive. Yes, of course, the simplest single-layer paper wallpapers are really very inexpensive, and here it is useless to equal them with plaster.

In general, it is difficult to say unequivocally that it will cost less, since there is a very large variation in prices depending on the quality of the coating. But if you analyze the averages, then yes - the wallpaper will cost less. In addition, almost everyone can cope with it, but for the normal application of plaster, you can’t do without professionals, and this is also the cost of work.

Appearance

We will not make the final decision on which material looks better. It is only worth noting that we all know what diversity reigns in the world of wallpaper: not only do they come in different types, but also options for all kinds of textures, colors, patterns, sparkles, etc. just amazing. But almost all of them, with the exception of liquid ones, form seams on the wall: they can be almost invisible, but they will still be present. In addition, wallpaper is a more typical option, but plaster can become unique, because even the same master will not repeat the same pattern twice. And some types of plasters, for example, Venetian, look very chic and expensive - here it is difficult for wallpaper to compete with them. Plaster, by the way, just like wallpaper, can imitate any surface: metal, stone, leather, fabric, wood, etc.

Installation and practicality

Of course, wallpapering has its own nuances, but, as a rule, it does not cause any particular difficulties, and everyone can cope with this matter with the proper level of care and concentration. Preparing walls for wallpapering is a separate issue. So, you can get by, of course, with simple priming, but in order for the result to be perfect, it is better to resort to a full range of work, and this is plastering, puttying, rubbing, several layers of primer, and only then - the pasting process itself. Some types of plaster are also not very difficult to apply, and with some, on the contrary, it is difficult to do without professionals.

Decorative plaster

And here in terms of practicality, plaster shows itself from a stronger side: when treated with a special protective compound, it can be washed, it behaves normally in the kitchen and is not afraid of humidity, ultraviolet rays, and the claws of pets cannot damage it. In this regard, the wallpaper loses: even if they are washable, it is quite easy to tear them, and not all types can be used in rooms such as the kitchen.

At home with children the question of the safety of the final coating may also arise: if you are afraid that the child may get hurt on the sharp parts of the plaster, then you can always choose a material that forms an almost smooth surface. Even from the point of view of children's wall paintings, plaster is better: with the help of detergents it will be possible to wash off all the drawings, but this will not work with wallpaper.

So which is better?

Liquid wallpaper

The answer to this question will vary depending on what are your goals. If you want to get the most durable, durable, well-resistant surface to moisture and washing, then it is better to choose plaster. And if you choose material, for example, in the living room, and at the same time have the means and desire to update the situation more or less often, then you can choose a cheaper option - wallpaper. And in appearance, these two types of finishes are equally worthy of attention: one for uniqueness, the second for countless colors and patterns.

If you still can’t decide what is best, then there is an option for this case - look at liquid wallpaper, because they actually combine the advantages of these two coatings: they are durable, can be washed, they are easy to apply, a perfectly flat surface is not required, and they are maintainable, and you can choose any color, and even create a pattern.

Finally it happened: you bought your own apartment or house! Maybe you just want to freshen up the interior of your office or cottage. And the question arose: what is cheaper wallpaper or decorative plaster? Neighbors advise the first, friends - the second. Let's look at the arguments to make a choice!

Wallpaper or decorative plaster Which is better?

Consider the performance characteristics, compare them.

• They have different composition. Paper, non-woven, vinyl, velor, textile. Service life - from 2 to 5-7 years.
• The main disadvantages: wear out in places of contact with furniture, near sockets, burn out over time.
• Some types can be refreshed: washed, dyed. However, in contact with water, peeling off, deformation of the seams is possible.

Decorative plaster:

• High strength characteristics, resistance to abrasion.
• Service life - up to 50 years.
• Does not soak under the influence of moisture, prevents the development of fungus and mold.
• Withstands multiple stains.

When comparing the performance properties, it becomes clear: the wallpaper loses on all counts. They are afraid of moisture, short-lived, on average after 5 years they require replacement.

Additionally, decorative plaster wins due to significant advantages:

• Special beauty. Overflows, the play of light on the created drawings. Unique texture.
• The ability to create unique decor elements: borders, frescoes, screen printing, drawings.

By beauty and strength, we choose: definitely, decorative plaster is better than wallpaper! But what about the price?

Wallpaper or decorative plaster What is cheaper?

Let's count! Good wallpapers cost about 2000 rubles / roll. This is about 250 rubles / sq.m. The cost of inexpensive decorative bark beetle plaster (the material itself) is approximately 130 rubles / sq.m. The difference is 120 rubles. will more than cover the cost of paint! This wall decoration looks much more impressive than the usual wallpaper, does not require replacement every 5 (!) Years.

And for 250 rubles / sq.m. approximately possible:

• Imitation of natural stone MARMO STUCCO NATURALE (approximate price 216 rubles/sq. m.) with color.
• Cover the surface with VERNICE OPACA matte varnish (48 rubles/sq. m.)

It comes out to 14 rubles. more expensive, but the effect is amazing:

It turns out that if you do the work yourself, the cost of materials is about the same. But if you calculate the cost of updating wallpaper for 50 years, then decorative plaster is much cheaper!

Add here the advantages in beauty, wide decor possibilities, expensive look - and the question of choice is obvious!